साथीभाइको कुरा पनि पढे अनि भिडियो पनि हेरे । त्यसपछी मलाई पनि केही कुरा लेख्न मन लाग्यो

हामीहरु सबैलाई थाहा छ एउटा विद्यार्थी कत्तिको पढ्ने र नपढ्ने हुने भन्ने कुरा उसले कत्तिको मिहेनत गर्छ भन्ने कुरामा भर पर्छ । तर काठमाडौको लैन्चौर डाँडामा जानु भयो भने आदर्श योग हरी मा बिको भित्तामा ठुलो ठुलो अक्षरले लेखेको देख्नुहुनेछ " विद्यार्थीले जानेका छैनन् भने शिक्षकले सिकाएका छैनन्" । मैले दिएको यो उदाहरण माथिको भिडियोको सन्दर्भमा ठ्यक्कै लागू नहुन पनि सक्छ । तर मेरो आशय के हो भने यसरी गरिने नाचगान कार्यक्रममा हरेक कुरा दुईतर्फी नै हुन्छ । दर्शकलाई मात्र के दोष? मैले माने धेरै नेपाली दर्शकहरु पश्चिमा गीत संगितमा रमाउन जान्दैनन् र जसले जानेका छन् जान्नु उनिहरुको अपराध होइन । अहिलेको बढ्दो विश्वव्यापिकरणको युगमा संसारको एउटा कुनामा भएको ज्ञान विज्ञान, कला संगित जस्ता हरेक कुराको जानकारी संसारको अर्को कुनामा रहेका मान्छेहरुले जान्न खोज्नु सामान्य मात्र होइन आवश्यक पनि भइसक्यो । तर आवश्यकता एकातिर हुन्छ यथर्थता एकातिर हुन्छ । नेपाली परिवेशमा भन्ने हो भन्ने यथार्थता के हो भने शकिराको लोभलाग्दो जिउ र उनको शरीरमा भएको लचकता देखेर थुप्रैले थुक निल्लान्, आँखा फराकिलो बनाउलान् तर उनले जस्तै संगितको तालमा आफ्नो नितम्ब हल्लाउन सबैले सक्दैनन् ।

अब कुरा रह्यो माथि भिडियोको न्रित्यगनाले शकिराको तालमा नाच्नु हुन्थ्यो कि हुँदैन थियो र त्यो न्रित्य हेरेर बसेका दर्शकले पनि उनकै तालमा आ-आफ्न नितम्ब हल्लाउन पर्थ्यो कि पर्दैन थियो भन्ने कुरा । ल नेपाली दर्शकहरु त काम न काजका गँवार नै भए तर ति नानीले कुन दर्शक समुदायलाई लक्षित गरेर आफ्नो कार्यक्रम प्रस्तुत गरिदै छ, तिनिहरुको कस्तो खालको गीत संगितमा रम्छन् भन्ने कुरा जान्नु आवश्यक छ कि छैन? शकिरा जस्तै आफ्नो नितम्ब हल्लाउन र कम्मर मर्काउन निसन्देह उनी माहिर छिन् तर दर्शकको रोजाइ बुझ्न र उनिहरुलाई कार्यक्रममा आफ्नो साथमा राख्न भने उनी असफल छिन् । ए बा आफू मात्र नाच्नलाई त ज जसको तालमा जे जे हल्लाए पनि भयो तर अरु समक्ष केही प्रस्तुत गर्ने हो भने आफ्नो होइन उनिहरुको रोजाइमा ध्यान दिनुपर्छ ।

अस्तु  

As creativity doesnot have any boundry or limits. For points you have raised, may organizer and sponsor should think about those details.

I believe she is good performer, and she did her best on this video, i also watched couple of videos on youtube, seems that she like to shake her body while singing, and not only for shakeera song.


अस्तु

JT,
You know how to comment  still on this matter I can not agree.
She is a performer , an artist but if anybody  see it with evil mind you see many things within their Imagination.

I am pretty sure the way the country is running , these maoist will run Exotic Dance club within 7-10 yrs, then what you going to say on that.

Gorkhe bro , you are such an stupid commenter man. You should act like real man , let me be clearify your questions 
1)Many things happen after 1990. you are stocked with your traditional thick mind who does not want to grow but just vomited your bias mind "संस्क्रिती का किरा".   : Country which is stuck in 1950 for development want dancers , gay bars and western culture as 2010 USA !!!
2)What do you say to those who had taken forcefully to Bombay market and selling thier body?  : Mathi ko dance ma yo kura ko link kasari bho dude? Dont tell me simple reason because they are both girls .
3)Demand and supply theory working well. : I am 100% sure those guys who were looking her wants her to be naked and perform so as your view she have to do it ??

@Ojawsi rana : I didnt delete any of your comment (ask SAN if you want to be sure ) so learn how to use sajha before you start commenting. and girl I cant take such great moves over my culture so u keep it by urself.

@GT bro , I respect your comment bro ! Just was trying to have some fun here no hard feelings.

Bro: When you use word, think before you use it.  You judged her. 

Think positively, she is a performer and that is her living.   Looks you're abroad and trying to reserve our culture.  Since 1990 we have jumped more than we imagine and our demands are rocketed in many ways.  Do not  concentrate on  b**bs shaking, but think it a dance and performing on the stage.

 

You do what you good at. She is good at dancing and she does that. If you aint good at what she does ,then shut the fuc* up and just do what you good at and make your living off of that.Tired of these people telling others what they should/shouldn't do....

To whom it may concern:

Hey Nepali Talibans ! STFU !!

I am just saying what i want to say so you guys STFO

i really think that she is a good performer and don't she where she is losing her culture ....like someone mentioned above she is doing what she does good and i dont see anything wrong about that. We should be proud that we have a good performer. its ok to praise someone for a good work and i see the audience praising for her..Stop being haters!!!!

Why can't u guys just enjoy the dance?

She is good performer thats her job and i dont mind paying to see that dance too. I was just trying to fit her dance with our culture thats all.
I am not taliban or against women or hater.
peace

Honestly,  she does not have a voice. Not for this song. Whenever she sings it goes bad. Its just that she is overlapping her singing over shakira that makes her sound slightly better.

Secondly, her dancing is poor. I have to be honest. I have seen a lot of girls who can shake their hips like shakira.  She got no grace and pace in her hip shakking.

If she is a good nepali singer may be she should stick to that. 

 effing trolls are everywhere... 
lol.. 

she's fabulous and dancing very good. I liked her. She also has a great voice and her english accent is  damn good as well. 

so, all the trolls STFU and enjoy the show.. 

हामी नेपाली लाई तुच्छ बचन प्रयोग र खसालेर बोल्न पाए ठुलाई मान्छे गनिने बाउ बाजे देखी लागेको बानी यो ईन्टरनेट चलाऊन जान्दैमा जादो रहेनछ ।
शायद हामी हिन्दू कुस बासी हरु जात पात को कारणले ठुलो र सानो बनाएको करणले यो पनि आफुलाई ठुलो देखाउने एक माध्यम हो कि ??

नितम्ब हल्लियो रे , छ अनी हल्लिन्छ आँखा जता लागायो तेही मात्रै देख्छौ ।   किन भन्नु पर्‍यो सन्स्कृतिका किरा ?

 purana bichardhara bro, purana bichardhara.. aba tesaiko chuhiyera aako ali kati baaki ras ganako ho.. aru kehi pani hoina.. tyo sab dhong haru aba ko 50-60 barsa ma bilayera jaaneycha. 

ahiley ko 21 century ma, global culture and globalization ko kura chali ra bela testo sanskriti ka kira bhanney thukka aadimanaab ho..  jau khayera gufaa ma basa

is she entertainer or just a singer ??

I love her, she's rock n roll,
I'm with her.. no matter what you trolls think.

put some cucumber in her ass then she can dance or move that belly better, not even close to shakira's ass

I don't think she's bad and she did sing few nepali numbers at the same concert (other youtube videos). I hope she sings more dance songs so that our stupid actresses won't have to dance wild in hindi numbers.
onlinekhabar.com/2011/12/112416.html

Her recent interview:
www.nepshow.com/2011/12/indira-joshi-nepali-singer-platform.html

mero kankra mukh ma ataudaina kasaiko.. tesma k atla ra..